Championing Archaeological Businesses

Category: Health & Safety News or Resource

  • A5WTC Phase 1A Archaeological Investigation: archaeology and CDM

    A5WTC Phase 1A Archaeological Investigation: archaeology and CDM

    FAME has written to Infrastructure Northern Ireland about their recent tender release in regards to CDM:

  • CSCS cards for archaeologists -a joint statement from CIfA and FAME

    CSCS cards for archaeologists -a joint statement from CIfA and FAME

    • CSCS is the leading skills certification scheme within the UK construction industry. CSCS cards provide proof that individuals working on construction sites have the required training and qualifications for the type of work they carry out.
    • The current system whereby most archaeologists gain CSCS accreditation will change in September 2017 when the current Construction Related Occupation (CRO) card is withdrawn. The CRO card was introduced in 2005 to cover occupations for which there was no nationally recognized qualification and does not require card-holders to demonstrate their skills.
    • CIfA and FAME have been working closely with CSCS to establish the appropriate mechanisms by which archaeologists can achieve CSCS accreditation following the withdrawal of the card. In line with other construction related professions, these will be based around vocational and/or academic qualifications and professional accreditation.
    • CIfA and FAME welcome the changes which recognize the high levels of expertise and skill required by archaeologists alongside other professionals in the construction industry. Both organisations are working hard to ensure that there is a smooth transition to the new arrangements for individuals and organisations.

    The following CSCS cards will be available for archaeologists

     Apprentices’ card – available to archaeologists on a recognised apprenticeship scheme provided it contains a basic health and safety element. Card valid for five years. No health and safety test required.

    Trainee card – available to students or trainees registered on a recognised training course. For an employers’ training scheme to be recognised by CSCS, it will need to be endorsed by CIfA, as the standards setting body for archaeology. CIfA will design a framework around National Occupational Standards, for all employers to use. Card valid for five years. Requires the basic (operative level) health and safety test.

    Academically Qualified Person (AQP) card – available to archaeologists with an ‘archaeology and heritage degree’. There is currently a lack of clarity from the scheme regarding what qualifies; to be resolved by CIfA, FAME and CSCS agreeing a list of courses. For reasons of pragmatism, these will be very broadly defined initially in order to ease the transition following the withdrawal of the CRO card. Requires the Manager level health and safety test. Valid for five years.

    Note: CSCS is proposing changes to the AQP route in future to ensure that candidates are able to demonstrate appropriate competence. CIfA and FAME understand that these changes will not be introduced for at least 6 months following the withdrawal of the CRO card.

    Professionally Qualified Person (PQP) card – Will be available at three levels, equating to Operative, Supervisor and Manager (= PCIfA, ACIfA, MCIfA) – and with the three corresponding health and safety tests (card to be clearly marked to indicate which level test had been taken). Approval has already been gained for the PCIfA level card which can be applied for NOW (agreed by FAME and CIfA as the priority). Mapping for ACIfA and MCIfA will be undertaken late 16/early 17.  CIfA membership at appropriate level will need to be maintained in order for cards to be renewed. Card valid for five years.

     The Site Visitor card will still be available for those who visit sites in a monitoring role (i.e. those not working directly on site). This card can be used by senior/project manages, by consultants, and local authority curatorial staff.

     NOTE: The CSCS website is currently being updated to reflect the new option for the PIfA level PQP card. As further changes are made through 2016/17 the site will continue to be updated.

    Who should I contact at CIfA or FAME for further help or advice?

    If you are a CIfA member or Registered Organisation please contact Anna Welch at CIfA at anna.welch@archaeologists.net

    For CIfA membership related enquiries, please contact Lianne Birney at lianne.birney@archaeologists.net

    At FAME, you should contact Nick Shepherd at info@famearchaeology.co.uk

    You can contact CSCS via their helpline on 0344 994 4777 or via their website at www.cscs.uk.com/contact-us.  There is also an online cardfinder https://www.cscs.uk.com/card-finder/.

    To read the full statement, including some useful FAQs CLICK HERE.

  • CSCS Cards -a quick update

    CSCS Cards -a quick update

    The current system whereby most archaeologists gain CSCS accreditation will change in September 2017 when the current Construction Related Occupation card is removed.

    CSCS are doing this, on behalf of the wider construction industry, in order to tighten up accreditation across all professional and technical occupations. In particular it is now clear that the primary purpose of the CSCS card is not simply to accredit an individual in health and safety competence, but competence in their main job role (i.e. as an archaeologist).

    To respond to this FAME and CIfA are currently in discussions with CSCS as to how competence can be demonstrated for archaeologists, and this is likely to be be either by professional accreditation (e.g. CIfA, or IHBC) or by academic or vocational qualification.

    FAME and CIfA will soon publish a joint statement outlining the proposals for CSCS accreditation and how these might affect archaeologists working on construction sites that require the cards.

    In the meantime CSCS will continue to issue cards under the existing system and cards already issued will continue to be recognised.

    FAME members have already been consulted on the progress of negotiations with CSCS and a copy of the late draft proposals are available in the members library, here.

     

  • CDM 2015 Revisions and Archaeology

    CDM 2015 Revisions and Archaeology

    The revised Construction (Design and Management) Regulations (CDM 2015) came into effect on the 6th April. The key changes have been well publicised, and the HSE has now provided FAME with clarity regarding their exemption for ‘pre-construction archaeological investigations’.

    The exemption means that archaeological investigation is not ‘construction work’ within the defined meaning, and is therefore not subject to the CDM regulations when undertaken as a stand-alone element prior to the construction phase of a construction project.  Therefore, pre-construction archaeological investigations are not construction activities and do not initiate the construction phase of a project

    However, archaeological investigations or activities that are undertaken during the construction phase of a project will be governed by the requirements of CDM – but archaeologists and their activities will be considered to be specialist contractors and will therefore comply with the directions of the PC and PD and take responsibility for the planning, management and monitoring of their own work – as any other contractor working in the construction phase of the project.

    The exemption has been included to ensure that archaeologists are not inadvertently burdened with the role of Principal Contractor for a project, just because they are often the first ‘contractor’ on a future site.  The role of Principal Contractor can only be assumed by a person or organization that has the skills, knowledge and experience required to fulfil the Principal Contractor duties across the whole project, from concept design, through build and ultimate handover of the new structure.

    The HSE have advised that the exemption is not to be seen as a diminution of the requirement for archaeologists to plan, manage, monitor and undertake their work safely. Even where the CDM exemption applies to archeology – all requirements of general workplace health and safety requirements including the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 and subsequent legislation i.e. the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, fully apply as they always have.

    Russell Adfield, HM Principal Inspector, Head of CDM Unit – Construction Sector, Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Construction Division – South East, The Council Offices, Station Road East, Oxted

    Surrey RH8 0BT

    russell.adfield@hse.gsi.gov.uk

    Issued by Dan Poore on behalf of FAME

    FAME CDM advice note April 2015

  • FAME Response to CDM 2015

    FAME Response to CDM 2015

    FAME has responded to the HSE consultation on the review of the CDM Regulations. There was a deep division of opinion among members about the proposal to exempt ‘pre-construction archaeological investigations’ from the revised regulations.

    Those in favour argued that CDM should not be triggered unnecessarily by pre-construction investigative work, and that exemption would provide greater clarity over the vexed question of archaeologists as Principal Contractors. Those against were concerned that exemption would marginalise archaeology from the construction process and potentially jeopardise health and safety.

    We have eventually decided to support the proposal in principle, with the caveats that a clear definition of ‘pre-construction’ is required, and that archaeology should be cited alongside other pre-construction investigative works within the regulations.

    We would like to see a clear statement that archaeological work during, or directly associated with, construction will fall within the regulations, and that in these circumstances archaeological organisations should be appointed as Specialist Contractors but not as Principal Contractors. We would also like to see greater clarity on health & safety training and accreditation, and on how archaeological documentation is included as part of the CDM design process, and would welcome the preparation of sectoral guidance on the regulations.

    The full FAME response is here.

    For those wishing to submit their own response, visit the HSE website.

  • CDM 2014 to exclude pre-construction archaeology?

    CDM 2014 to exclude pre-construction archaeology?

    A new consultation by HSE proposes that pre-construction archaeological work will be excluded from the new CDM Regulations.

    The 10-week consultation on proposals to replace the Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2007, launched yesterday, states that “the definition of construction work is substantially unchanged from CDM 2007, except for clarification that it does not include pre-construction archaeological investigations” (33). This is reiterated in the Interpretation (regulation 2(1)) and Explanatory Note 3(c) of the Consultation Draft Regulations. The full consultation document may be viewed here and on the HSE website.

    This proposal reflects the outcome of discussions with HSE over the past four years, led since November 2012 by the FAME Health & Safety Working Group, and was first announced by HSE at last year’s FAME Forum.

    FAME will of course be responding to the consultation through its Health and Safety Working Group, and any comments on the proposals should be sent to its convenor, Andrew Townsend.

  • FAME Forum: HSE to consult on CDM exemption for archaeology

    FAME Forum: HSE to consult on CDM exemption for archaeology

    The HSE are to consult on exempting pre-construction archaeological investigation from the definition of ‘construction work’ for the purposes of the new CDM Regulations, they have announced at the FAME Forum. Consultation on the new regulations, due to be introduced in October 2014, will start in September this year. The exemption would not apply to archaeological work during construction, for which archaeological contractors would be classed as specialist contractors under the regulations . HSE reiterated their view that it would be inappropriate under normal circumstances for archaeological contractors to be Principal Contractors under the terms of the regulations. FAME’s Health and Safety Working Party will be co-ordinating a response to the consultation, and working with HSE to develop industry-specific guidance.

    The magnificent setting of the FAME Forum at the Merchant Taylors Hall (photo York Archaeological Trust
    Merchant Taylors Hall, the magnificent setting for the Forum (photo York Archaeological Trust)

    Understanding your insurance obligations Tariq Mian, Towergate Insurance

    Why do you need adequate insurance cover, and why is it important to understand what insurance you are buying? This paper will examine Public Liability, Employers Liability and Professional indemnity Insurance, and will consider questions such as where they are compulsory, what they cover, and what implications they have in terms of risk management.

    It will also discuss risk exposure as a director, officer or trustee of a company or charity: how your decisions can affect you personally, and how you can insure against getting it wrong through directors, officers or charity trustees liability insurance. It will also consider business interruption – insuring your cash flow and what you need to know about it, and insuring your assets and why it is important to keep your broker or insurer informed. It will include some examples of claims, and will provide an opportunity for questions and discussion.

    Investing in staff – a risk worth taking? Reviewing the skills and training statistics from Profiling the Profession 2012–13 Kenneth Aitchison, Director, Landward Research Ltd

    Profiling the Profession 2012-13 was the UK’s fourth quinquennial archaeology labour market intelligence gathering exercise. The data stretch back to 1997, and the headline figures of the number of archaeologists in employment that rose to a peak in 2007-08 have come crashing downwards since. In a shrinking profession, with an asymmetrical oversupply of untrained would-be entrants, the data on skills and training are particularly interesting, especially when read alongside the (strongly) opinionated comments that some respondents to the survey generously provided.

    When we look at our competitors, the archaeological profession thinks there is a widespread problem. Archaeology lacks professional skills – we think the sector as a whole needs better data management, leadership, business skills, education and training – but as individual employers, we rarely recognise these as being areas where we would invest in training our own staff or we would consider buying in outside help. This mismatch, and whether it might represent an opportunity, is the key issue that archaeological employers and managers need to be considering.

    John Walker receives his award of Honorary Life President of FAME (photo York Archaeological Trust)
    John Walker receives his FAME Honorary President award (photo York Archaeological Trust)

    Sharing Financial Risk: The Application of Measured Contract Practices to Archaeological Contracting Michael Heaton, Michael Heaton Heritage Consultants

    Uncertainty of financial outcome, borne of the inherent unpredictability of archaeological investigation, is arguably the principal obstacle to the fulfilment of archaeological contracting as a commercial and intellectual undertaking. It causes stress in what should be an intellectually-rewarding pursuit, and hinders investment in skills and public engagement. That uncertainty of outcome is largely the result of unsophisticated contract practices based on ‘lump sum’ and so-called ‘fixed price’ contracts, naively adopted in the years either side of PPG16 and left unchallenged. 

    Civil engineering groundworks – the commercial undertaking most readily comparable to archaeological contracting – is invariably undertaken on the basis of ‘Measured’ contracts, in which the contractor is paid for what they have had to do, not what someone thought they might have to do. Such contracts explicitly acknowledge the inherent unpredictability of groundworks, share the financial risk between contractor and client, and are accepted throughout the international construction industry. They are directly applicable to archaeological contracting.

    This short paper presents the author’s experience, as a consultant, of applying such practices to archaeological excavations in southern England, and his thoughts on how the method could be adapted for more widespread use in archaeological contracting. It is based, in part, on the author’s Construction Management coursework undertaken for a Graduate Diploma in Building Surveying at the University of the West of England, and his on-going discussions with UWE teaching staff and fellow professionals.

    Which Archaeologist? Improving commercial practice, understanding value and risk Tim Malim, SLR Consulting Ltd

    The successful development of commercial archaeology over the past 25 years has generated opportunities for graduate careers, produced a massive output of archaeological data, and led to increased professionalism. Commercial archaeology is driven, however, by developer-funding, and the down-side of this success story has been the operational difficulties caused by price competition within a largely unregulated market place. Other professions have developed educational pathways and business practices that allow them to operate effectively as part of the development process, and commercial archaeology now needs to develop similar strategies, as well as developing complementary skill sets to increase value to their paymasters.

    As a profession, simply understanding the nuts and bolts of the discipline and how we can practically apply archaeological investigation is insufficient to be a successful business. In future archaeologists need to become fully-fledged members of development project teams, with a wide knowledge of legislation and the planning process beyond just the historic environment, and they will need to execute rigorous business and financial planning, to operate effective methods of project management and quality assurance, and develop partnerships to maximise value and opportunity within development schemes. This paper will explore what mechanisms exist to help us improve quality and identify risk, so that clients can make better value judgements on which archaeologist they should appoint.

    Democracy at work at the FAME AGM at Barley Hall (photo York Archaeological Trust)
    Democracy in action at the AGM at Barley Hall (photo York Archaeological Trust)